He turned to a page near the end of the will and read it out loud.
“The first one is simple,” he said. “If any part of this estate is ever given to Daniel Brooks, by you or by anybody, that part goes immediately to the Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Foundation instead.” He looked up. “Your grandfather didn’t want your father to be able to pressure you. He wanted to make sure nobody could ever take this from you the way they took your mother’s money.”
I nodded slowly.
“The second one,” he said, “is the one he called the condition. He made me promise I’d say it to you in his exact words.” He read from the page. “Before my grandson receives anything beyond what he needs to live, he must personally deliver the sealed envelope marked Daniel to his father, and he must be in the room while his father reads it. He does not have to say anything. He does not have to forgive anyone. But he must be there.”
Mr. Hartwell reached into his desk drawer and took out a white envelope. It was thick and sealed with old-fashioned red wax. On the front, in the same shaky hand from the photograph, it said one word. Daniel.
“I don’t want to see him,” I said. My voice shook. “I don’t ever want to see him again.”
“I know,” Mr. Hartwell said. “Your grandfather knew that too. That’s why he made it a condition and not a request.”
“What’s in it?”
“I don’t know. He wrote it himself, two weeks before he died, and sealed it in front of me.” Mr. Hartwell set the envelope on the desk between us. “But I knew James Brooks for thirty-one years. And I can tell you he wasn’t a man who did anything without a reason.”
Chapter Seven: What Grandpa Wrote to Me
He gave me one more thing before I left his office that day. A second envelope, plain, with my own name on it.
“This one’s yours,” he said. “You can read it whenever you’re ready. Alone, if you want.”
I read it that night in the hotel room, sitting on the edge of the bed with the lights off and only the lamp on the desk.
Dear Nathan, it said. If you’re reading this, Richard found you, and I’m gone. I’m sorry I never got to see your face. The investigator showed me your yearbook picture. You have your mother’s eyes and my stubbornness, God help you.
I need to tell you the truth, and I need you to hear all of it, even the parts that make me look bad.
I was a hard father to your dad. When he was a boy, I worked eighty hours a week building my printing business, and when I came home, I was angry and tired and I had no patience. I told him he’d never amount to anything. I told him he was soft. I hit him once, when he was fifteen, and he never forgave me for it, and he was right not to. When he married your mother, I told him she was too good for him. I said it at their wedding. I’ve spent twenty years ashamed of that day.
When your mother died, I went to court to ask for visitation with you. Your father thought I was trying to take you away from him. Maybe I handled it badly. I was grieving her too. She called me Dad, Nathan. She was the only one who ever did. Your father won, and he moved you to Hamilton, and he told me if I ever came near you, he’d make sure you never knew I existed. I believed him. I was a coward. I let sixteen years go by.
I don’t know what kind of man your father became. Richard tells me some of it, and it breaks my heart. But I know where he learned to be cruel to a son. He learned it from me.
That’s why I need you to give him my letter. Not for him. For you. So that whatever you decide about him, you’ll decide it knowing everything. So you never have to wonder, the way I wondered for sixteen years.
You don’t owe him anything. But I owe him something. And I’m too late to give it to him myself.
Your grandfather, James.
I sat on the edge of that hotel bed and held the letter in my lap for a long time. Then I took out the rubber band from the stack of my mother’s envelopes, and I opened the first one, dated April 2007, three months before I was born.
Dear little one, it began. I don’t know yet if you’re a boy or a girl. But I already know I’ll never leave you.
I read all thirty of them that night. I didn’t sleep at all.
Chapter Eight: Millville Avenue
I went to the house on Millville Avenue on a Saturday afternoon in April, three weeks after the dumpster. Mr. Hartwell drove me in his gray Lexus. He offered to come inside. I told him no. I told him the will said I had to be there, not him.
“I’ll be right here,” he said, parking at the curb exactly where my blue Malibu used to sit. “If you need me, just open the front door. I’ll come.”
I walked up the front walk with the sealed envelope in my hand. I rang the doorbell. I heard footsteps.
Tyler opened the door.
He stood there in the doorway in sweatpants and a Miami University T-shirt, and when he saw me, his face went white. He didn’t say anything for a long time. Then he stepped out onto the porch and pulled the door almost shut behind him.
“Nate,” he said, very quietly. “Where have you been? I looked for you. I drove around for two weeks.”
I stared at him. “You looked for me?”
“Every night after work,” he said. “Behind the Kroger. The laundromat. I didn’t know where you’d go.” He swallowed. “I didn’t know about the money, Nathan. I swear to God. Carla told me the deposit came from a scholarship. I found out from Dad a week after you left, when he was yelling at her about the credit card bill. I didn’t know it was yours.”
He reached into the back pocket of his sweatpants and took out a folded envelope. A manila envelope, creased and soft. My envelope. The one I’d taped under my bed.
“It’s not all there,” he said. “Carla spent the rest. But I got the Miami deposit refunded. They let you cancel before May first. Five hundred dollars.” He held it out. “And I put in two weeks of my own checks from the warehouse. It’s eleven hundred and forty. I’ll pay you the rest. I promise.”
I looked at the envelope in his hand. My handwriting was still on the front. Nathan. Escape Fund. Do Not Touch.
“Why?” I asked.
Tyler looked at the ground. “Because you drove me home from the Fourth of July party when I was too drunk to stand,” he said. “Junior year. And you never told anybody.” He pushed the envelope into my hand. “And because what they did to you was wrong. I should have said it at the table. I was a coward.”
I took it. I didn’t know what else to do.
“Is he home?” I asked.
Tyler nodded. “In the kitchen.”
Chapter Nine: The Kitchen Table
My father was sitting at the head of the kitchen table, the same chair, the same spot. Carla was at the sink with her back to the door. When I walked in, she turned around and dropped a plate. It shattered on the floor. Nobody moved to pick it up.
Dad stared at me. He looked older than three weeks ought to make a man look. There were dark circles under his eyes, and he hadn’t shaved.
“Nathan,” he said.
I didn’t say hello. I didn’t sit down. I walked up to the table and set the sealed envelope down in front of him.
“Your father wrote you a letter,” I said. “Before he died. Three weeks ago.”
My father looked at the envelope. At the one word on the front in that shaky handwriting. Daniel. His face changed. All the color went out of it, like water down a drain.
“He’s dead,” Dad said. Not a question.
“He was alive my whole life,” I said. “You told me he died before I was born. He was forty minutes away. In Hyde Park. He spent six months looking for me.”
Carla made a small sound at the sink.
“His lawyer found me,” I said. “Digging in a dumpster behind an Italian restaurant on Hamilton Cleves Road. Nine days after you locked the door.”
My father didn’t say anything. He just stared at the envelope.
