The Title
The sheet of paper was the Ohio Certificate of Title for a 1966 Ford Mustang.
Owner: Dorothy and August Kowalski.
When Dottie died, the car passed to me. I’d never signed it over to anyone. On Lily’s birthday, I’d handed her the keys and a bow, but I’d planned to take her to the BMV the following week, just the two of us, to put the title in her name properly. I’d even booked the appointment.
Which meant that legally, the car Brent had listed for $38,000, and taken a deposit on, wasn’t his. It wasn’t even Lily’s yet.
It was mine.
Midnight
Ray picked me up at 11:50 p.m. in his flatbed. We’ve been friends since we were nine years old. He didn’t ask a single question. He just said, “Dottie’s car?” and I nodded.
Brent’s house was dark. The Mustang was parked in the driveway next to the Range Rover. Brent hadn’t even put it in the garage.
I unlocked the door with my spare key. That old 289 started on the first turn, quiet as I could make it. I drove it slowly up onto Ray’s flatbed, and we strapped it down.
Before we left, I took an envelope out of my jacket and tucked it under the windshield wiper of Brent’s Range Rover.
Inside were a photocopy of the title, with my name highlighted in yellow, and a note in my shaky handwriting:
“Brent, you can’t sell what isn’t yours. This car belonged to my wife, and now to me, and in one week it will belong to Lily. Not to you. Return that buyer’s deposit. If you want to talk, you know where my garage is. — Gus”
Then Ray and I drove Dottie’s Mustang home and parked it back in my garage, right where it had lived for twenty years.
Twenty-Six Calls
Brent found the empty driveway at 6:40 a.m.
The first call came at 6:42. Then 6:44. Then 6:45. By 8 a.m., there were 26 missed calls.
I listened to the voicemails over coffee.
“Gus, this is theft! I’m calling the police!”
He did call the police. An officer came to my garage around nine. I showed him the title. He looked at it, looked at the Mustang, looked at me, and grinned.
“Sir, this is your car. You can’t steal your own car.” Then he leaned in. “My dad had a ’67. Beautiful work.”
The voicemails after that changed tone.
“Gus, look. The buyer’s driving in from Indianapolis tomorrow. He already paid a $5,000 deposit. I already spent part of it. Please, call me back.”
He’d already spent part of a deposit on a car he didn’t own.
The Buyer
The buyer, a polite man named Harold from Indianapolis, eventually called me himself. Brent had given him my number, hoping I’d “make a deal.”
I told Harold the whole story. Dottie, the two years, the birthday, the rust bucket.
There was a long silence on the line.
“Mr. Kowalski,” Harold said finally, “I lost my wife last year. I wouldn’t buy that car now for a million dollars. I’ll get my deposit back from your son-in-law. You give that car to your granddaughter.”
Brent had to pay back the full $5,000 within the week. Harold made sure of it.
Carol
That afternoon, my daughter showed up at my garage with red eyes.
“Dad,” she said, “I didn’t know he listed it. I swear I didn’t know. When Lily showed me last night, I—” She stopped and looked at the Mustang. “That’s Mom’s car. He called it a rust bucket in front of everyone. And I just stood there.”
“You said ‘that’s enough,’” I told her. “That was more than anyone else said.”
She ran her hand over the hood. “It looks exactly like it did when I was little. You did all of this yourself?”
“Two years. Every day.”
She opened the glove box and found her mother’s sunglasses and the coral lipstick. Carol sat down in the driver’s seat and cried for twenty minutes, and I let her.
That night, Carol told Brent that if he ever tried to sell anything belonging to her family again, he could find somewhere else to live. I’ve heard he slept on the couch for a week.
Brent Comes to the Garage
Ten days later, Brent showed up at my garage. No beer. No sunglasses. He stood in the doorway like a kid called to the principal’s office.
“Gus,” he said. “I was wrong. About the car. About what I said. About… a lot of things.”
I wiped my hands on a rag and waited.
“My dad never gave me anything,” he said quietly. “Not his time, not his attention. Nothing. When I saw you hand Lily that car, and she looked at you like that… I think I was jealous. Of a seventy-four-year-old man. Pretty stupid, huh?”
“Pretty human,” I said. Then I tossed him a pair of work gloves. “The Mustang needs an oil change. You ever done one?”
He hadn’t. He got oil on his expensive shirt and said a word I won’t repeat. But he came back the next Saturday. And the one after that.
The BMV
A week after the birthday, just as I’d planned, I drove Lily to the BMV in Dottie’s Mustang. We waited in line for an hour and forty minutes. Neither of us minded.
When the clerk printed the new title, Owner: Lily Dorothy Mercer, Lily held it against her chest like it was a diploma.
Brent paid to have airbag-style lap-and-shoulder belts installed, the right way, by a classic car shop, so she’d be safe. It was his idea. Lily drives it to college now, two hours away, and calls me every Sunday from the parking lot.
“Grandpa,” she said last week, “people stop me at every gas station. They all want to know who restored it.”
“What do you tell them?”
“I tell them my grandpa did. For my grandma. And that it’s not for sale. Not for any price.”
She still keeps Dottie’s sunglasses in the glove box. Sometimes, she told me, she wears the coral lipstick on the first day of every semester. For luck.
This story is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and events are products of the author’s imagination. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental.