“How am I supposed to say it? Sarah.” She lowered her voice, leaned across the table. “You’re marrying the homeless man who lives at your subway stop.”
“He’s dying, Dana. Liver failure. He’s got a month, maybe less. He doesn’t want to be buried as a nobody. If I marry him, I can claim him. I can make sure he gets—” I heard my own voice crack and hated it. “I can make sure somebody buries him with his name.”
Dana was quiet for a second. She reached over and put her hand on mine.
“Honey,” she said. “This is a lot. Even for you.”
“What does that mean, even for me?”
“You know what it means.” She wasn’t being cruel. Dana was never cruel. “You collect people. You always have. The intern nobody would train, you trained him. Your neighbor with the leg, you did her grocery runs for four months. You are the person who fixes things. And I love that about you. But you can’t fix dying, Sarah.”
“I’m not trying to fix dying,” I said. “I’m trying to fix the paperwork.”
She looked at me for a long time.
“And after?” she said. “When it’s done. When he’s gone. What then?”
I didn’t have an answer. I hadn’t thought about after. I’d only thought about the problem in front of me, the clean solvable problem, the way I always did.
“Then I’ll have done a good thing,” I said.
Dana squeezed my hand and let it go.
“You’re a good person,” she said. “I just hope this is for him and not for you.”
I didn’t understand what she meant.
Now, thinking back, I think she saw it before I did. She saw that I needed to be needed the way some people need to be loved. That I’d built a whole life out of showing up for other people so I’d never have to sit still long enough to notice how alone I was.
Larry saw it too.
He saw it better than anyone.
Two days later, we went to the courthouse.
Larry wore a clean blue button-down shirt. Someone at the shelter had given it to him, he said, though it hung loose on his shoulders because he’d lost so much weight. He’d washed his face and combed his hair and he looked, for one afternoon, like a regular man dressed up for something.
I wore my navy work dress. The nice one. I’m not sure why I bothered. Some part of me must have felt it mattered.
The courthouse waiting room was full of couples. A woman in a white jumpsuit was fixing her lipstick in a compact while her fiancé held her little bouquet like it might explode. A toddler was crawling under the plastic chairs, and his father kept diving after him and coming up empty-handed. Everyone looked nervous and happy, the way people look before they promise something big.
Larry and I sat in a row near the back.
He kept rubbing his palms against his pants. Back and forth. Back and forth.
“You’re shaking,” I said.
He looked down at his own hands like they belonged to someone else.
“I’m dying,” he said. “I’m allowed to shake.”
I accepted that. Of course I accepted that. What else would it be? The man was in liver failure. His hands were supposed to shake.
I didn’t think about it again for a long time.
When they called our names, we went into a small room with a wooden arch against one wall. A clerk read us the words. Larry answered when he was supposed to answer, his voice steady even though his hands weren’t.
When the clerk got to the part about rings, Larry patted his shirt pocket.
“Knew I forgot something.”
The clerk smiled. She’d clearly heard it before.
I laughed. A few of the people waiting glanced over.
Then the clerk had us sign. Larry asked twice where his signature went. Twice. A man who, it turned out, had spent twenty-eight years working in that exact building, asking a junior clerk where to sign his own marriage license.
I teased him.
“You’re acting like this is a real wedding.”
He went quiet for a second. Just a second. Then he smiled at me, and there was something underneath the smile I didn’t read at the time.
“First marriage,” he said. “Let me have my nerves.”
I laughed again.
Eleven minutes after we walked in, I was Larry’s wife.
Outside, on the courthouse steps, I bought us celebratory hot dogs from a cart because it felt like we should do something. Larry ate his slowly. He folded up his copy of the marriage certificate and tucked it into his shirt pocket, and he pressed his hand flat over it for a second, like he was making sure it was still there.
“You okay?” I asked.
“Never better,” he said.
And I believed him, because believing him was easier than asking what else might be true.
The three weeks we had after that went fast and slow at the same time, the way the last part of anything always does.
Larry moved into the state hospice facility. I’d arranged it, of course. I’d made the calls and filled out the forms and argued with an intake coordinator until she found him a bed. It was clean and quiet and smelled like disinfectant and something floral underneath, and Larry had a bed by a window that looked out at a parking lot.
“Room with a view,” he said the first day.
I visited every evening after work.
And every single visit started the same way.
I’d walk in carrying something. Better socks, because his old ones had holes. A phone charger, so he could reach me. A new blanket, because I decided the hospital one was too thin. A whole bag of toiletries once, enough for six months, which was a strange thing to buy a man who had three weeks.
I’d come through the door already talking, already unpacking, already looking for a nurse to flag down about something.
And Larry would say, from the bed: “Sit down, Sarah.”
And I’d say, “In a minute.”
There was always another minute of something to do. Another form at the front desk. Another nurse to ask about his pain medication. Another problem I could put my hands on. I’d fluff his pillow and organize his side table and refill his water cup and check the schedule and do everything except the one thing he actually asked me to do.
“You bought me socks again,” he said one evening, holding up the new pack.
“Your feet were cold.”
“My feet are always cold. I’m dying. That’s a feature, not a bug.” He set the socks down. “Sit down, Sarah.”
“I want to talk to that nurse about your—”
“Sarah.”
“—medication, because you said last night it wasn’t lasting—”
“Sarah.” His voice was soft but it stopped me. “The socks are great. Thank you. Sit down.”
I sat. On the very edge of the chair, ready to spring up again. He watched me do it and shook his head a little, but he was smiling.
“You know what you are?” he said.
“What am I?”
“You’re a hummingbird. You never land. You just hover over a thing and drink from it and zip off to the next thing.”
“That’s not true.”
“You’ve been here nine minutes and you’ve stood up four times.”
I opened my mouth to argue and then closed it, because I realized I was, at that very moment, half out of my seat.
I sat back down.
“See,” he said. “You can do it. Now don’t move.”
We talked. About nothing, mostly, the way we always had. The pigeons. My terrible shoes, which he continued to insult from his deathbed. A game show playing on the little wall-mounted TV. He told me a story about a coworker from some job he’d once had, a man who ate a hard-boiled egg at his desk every single day at exactly ten in the morning, and how the whole office could set their watches by the smell.
“Where’d you work?” I asked. “You’ve never told me. What did you do, before?”
Larry looked at the ceiling.
“Little bit of this,” he said. “Little bit of that.”
“That’s not an answer.”
“It’s the answer you’re getting.” But he said it gently. “Ask me something else.”
I let it go. I let a lot of things go with Larry, because it was easier, and because I thought we had more time to get to the hard questions.
We didn’t.
Our last Tuesday, I brought coffee.
Not from the kiosk. He couldn’t really drink it by then. But I brought a cup anyway and set it on his side table, black, just so the room would smell right. Just so it would feel like one of our mornings.
He was smaller by then. The yellow had gone deeper. His voice came out thin.
“You staying?” he asked when I sat down.
“Five minutes,” I said. Old habit.
He smiled, and it took effort.
“Big spender.”
I stayed twelve.
I didn’t mean to. I meant to check on his chart and refill his water and flag down a nurse and do all my usual things, but for some reason that evening I just sat. I held his hand, which was cold, and I didn’t get up, and I didn’t fix anything, and we didn’t even talk much. The TV murmured. The parking lot lights came on outside the window.
At one point he turned his head and looked at me.
“This is nice,” he said.
“What is?”
“This.” He moved his fingers a little in mine. “You. Sitting. Not running around.”
“I run around because I care about you, you know.”
“I know.” He closed his eyes. “But this is better.”
Twelve minutes. Then I told him I’d see him tomorrow, and I kissed his forehead, and I left.
He died that night, sometime after two in the morning. The nurse who called me said it was peaceful. She said he wasn’t alone, that she’d been in the room. I’ve held onto that. I don’t know if it’s true, exactly the way she said it, but I’ve held onto it.
Those twelve minutes were the last time I saw him awake.
I keep thinking about that. About how I almost only gave him five.
The funeral was small.
I paid for it, which felt right, and I picked a plot in a quiet cemetery under a tree, because Larry had once mentioned he liked trees more than people, “and they don’t ask you for anything.”
Dana came, and stood next to me, and held my arm. A few people from the shelter came. And two older folks I didn’t recognize, a man and a woman, stood at the back the whole time and left before I could ask who they were. I assumed they were shelter volunteers. I found out later I was wrong.
The minister I’d hired hadn’t known Larry, so he read the generic words, the ones about ashes and dust, and I stood there in the cold and felt like a fraud. Because I realized, standing at his grave, that I’d married the man and buried the man and I didn’t know where he was from, or if he had a family somewhere, or what he’d done for twenty-eight years, or a single true thing about his life before the day he sat down on that concrete.
I thought I knew Larry.
I knew his coffee order.
We lowered him into the ground, and I put a hand on the casket, and I said the only thing I could think of.
“He’s mine,” I said, quietly, so only I could hear it. “I took him.”
I thought that was the end of it.
Then his letter came.
I’ve told you the beginning of the letter. Let me tell you the rest, because I read it in pieces over that whole terrible day, and each piece knocked something loose in me.
After the first two lines, the ones that turned me cold, I made myself keep reading at the kitchen table.
“The liver failure was real. The month was real. The lie was why I asked you to marry me.”
I read that three times.
“My arrangements were already handled,” he wrote. “Long before I ever met you. I knew somebody from hospice or the county would deal with the paperwork when the time came. I was never going to disappear without a name. That part, the John Doe part, I made it up. I made it sound worse than it was because I knew if I handed you a problem, a clean one you could solve, you’d solve it. You always did. If I gave you a problem you could solve, I knew you’d solve it.”
I stood up so fast my chair scraped back and nearly tipped over.
“What did you do, Larry?” I said out loud, to my empty kitchen.
But there was nowhere for the anger to go. That was the worst part. He was dead. I couldn’t call him. I couldn’t storm into the hospice and demand an explanation. I couldn’t even make him sit through the look on my face, the way he’d made me sit in that chair.
He’d figured out how to get the last word by dying with it in his pocket.
I paced my apartment. I got angry, then confused, then angry again. Because he was right. That was the thing that hurt the most. He’d read me exactly right. If he’d walked up to me two years in and simply said, “Sarah, I’m lonely, will you marry me so I’m not alone,” I don’t know what I would have said. It would have been messy. It would have been a feeling, not a task.
But turn it into a form? A burial? A problem with a clear solution?
I’d said yes in about four seconds flat.
I sat back down and forced myself to read the last line on that first page.
“Before you decide what kind of jerk I was,” he’d written, “go back to the courthouse where we got married. Ask for Margaret. Tell her you’re my wife.”
I almost threw the whole letter in the trash. I got as far as standing over the garbage can with it in my hand.
But I didn’t.
An hour later, I was on the train.
The courthouse looked exactly the way it had three weeks earlier. The same plastic chairs, the same nervous couples, the same fluorescent buzz. A woman was fixing her lipstick. A different toddler was crawling under a different set of chairs.
I stood in the lobby and remembered sitting there with Larry, watching him rub his palms on his pants.
“You’re shaking,” I’d told him.
“I’m dying. I’m allowed to shake.”
And I’d accepted it. Because it was easier than asking another question.
Standing there now, I wondered how many things I’d accepted in my life simply because the harder answer would have cost me something.
I went to the records counter. A young clerk looked up.
“I’m looking for Margaret?” I said.
