Two Boys Emptied My Daughters Savings Jar Until I Taught Their Mother A Lesson

Matt and I talked about it that night.

We could have just bought it for her. We’re not rich, but we could have. Her birthday was in April. We could have wrapped it up with a big bow.

But Matt had an idea.

“What if she saves for it?” he said. “Part of it. We’ll match whatever she saves. Dollar for dollar. But she has to put in the work.”

“She’s six, Matt.”

“I know,” he said. “That’s the perfect age. That’s when you learn this stuff. Money doesn’t grow on trees. You want something, you work for it. You save for it. And when you finally get it, it means something.”

He was quiet for a moment.

“I wish somebody had taught me that at six,” he said.

I didn’t know what he meant. Not then.


So we sat Elsie down at the kitchen table the next morning.

We explained the plan. Every dollar she saved, we’d match it. When she got to eighty dollars, we’d add eighty, and that would be enough for the bike. Plus tax.

“Eighty dollars,” Elsie repeated.

“Eighty dollars.”

“How long does that take?”

“It depends,” Matt said. “On how hard you work.”


She got a jar.

A pink plastic jar with a screw-top lid that used to have cheese puffs in it. She peeled the label off herself. She decorated it with stickers. Unicorns and rainbows and one sticker of a taco that she said was “for luck.”

On the front, she taped a piece of paper. She wrote on it herself, in purple marker, very carefully, with her tongue sticking out the side of her mouth the whole time.

BIKE MUNY.

She put it on her dresser. Right in the middle. Where she could see it from her bed.


And then she started saving.

Every dollar. Every quarter. Every penny.

She got a dollar a week for setting the table and feeding our cat, Biscuit. She put every single one in the jar.

She got five dollars from the tooth fairy when her front tooth fell out in February. She put it in the jar.

She got twenty dollars from Grandma Linda for her birthday in April. She put it in the jar.

She found a quarter in the couch cushions. She put it in the jar.

She sold lemonade on our front porch on the first warm Saturday in April. Fifty cents a cup. She made eleven dollars and fifty cents. Mostly from our neighbor Mr. Kowalski, who bought six cups and said it was the best lemonade he’d ever tasted, even though I’d forgotten to put enough sugar in it.

She put it all in the jar.


She counted it every night.

Every single night before bed. She’d take the jar down off her dresser and sit on the floor of her room with her legs crossed and dump it all out on the carpet. She’d sort it into piles. Dollars. Quarters. Dimes. Nickels. Pennies.

She’d count each pile. Out loud. Very slowly. Then she’d write the total on a little notepad she kept next to the jar.

Then she’d put it all back in the jar and put the jar back on the dresser and climb into bed.

“How much tonight, Els?” I’d ask from the doorway.

She’d tell me. Every night. The exact amount.

$12.75.

$23.50.

$41.25.


By the middle of May, she had eighty-seven dollars and forty cents.

She’d done it. More than she needed. She’d been saving for four months.

That night, she sat on the floor of her room and counted it three times. Then she wrote it on the notepad and drew a big star next to it.

“Mommy,” she said. “I did it.”

“You did it, baby.”

“Can we get the bike now?”

“This weekend,” I said. “Saturday. We’ll go to Target and get it. Daddy will match it, just like he promised.”

She looked at the jar for a long time.

“I want to count it one more time on Saturday morning,” she said. “Before we go. To make sure.”

“Okay.”

“And then I want to carry it into the store myself. And give it to the lady.”

“Okay, baby.”

She climbed into bed. She lay there looking at the jar on her dresser.

“Four more days,” she whispered.



Now I have to tell you about Piper.


Piper is Matt’s older sister. She’s thirty-eight. She lives about fifteen minutes away from us, in Blue Springs. She has two boys. Tucker is ten. Brody is eight.

I’m going to try to be fair here. I really am.

Piper’s not a monster. She’s funny. She’s loud. She’s the kind of person who walks into a room and everybody turns to look at her. She tells great stories. She does a perfect impression of every one of their relatives.

And she loves her boys. I’ve never once doubted that.

But those boys have never heard the word “no.”

Not once in their lives.


They take things.

Every time they come to our house, something goes missing. Or gets broken. Or gets taken home.

Elsie’s Barbie camper. Brody took it home in his backpack last summer. We found out three weeks later when Piper posted a picture on Facebook of Brody playing with it in her backyard.

Elsie’s tablet. Tucker grabbed it out of her hands at Thanksgiving because he wanted to play Minecraft. When she cried and asked for it back, he held it over his head where she couldn’t reach it.

Elsie’s Halloween candy. All of it. The whole pillowcase. Gone, the day after Halloween, when Piper brought the boys over “just to say hi.” Tucker had a mouth full of Reese’s when they left.

And every single time, Piper brushed it off.

“Oh, they’re just kids! Don’t be so uptight!”


I’d try to say something. Gently.

“Piper, Brody took Elsie’s camper home.”

“Did he? Huh. I’ll look for it.”

She never looked for it.

“Piper, Tucker won’t give Elsie her tablet back.”

“Tucker. Give it back.” Then, to me, laughing: “He’ll give it back. Boys, right? They just love electronics.”

He didn’t give it back. Not until Matt went over and took it out of his hands.

“Piper, the boys ate all of Elsie’s Halloween candy.”

“Oh, Caroline. It’s candy. She doesn’t need all that sugar anyway. Honestly, they did her a favor.”


Matt never said much.

That was the thing that drove me crazy. He’d sit there at Thanksgiving dinner while Tucker held Elsie’s tablet over his head, and his jaw would get tight, and a little muscle would jump in his cheek. But he wouldn’t say anything.

Later, in the car, I’d ask him.

“Why don’t you ever say anything to her?”

He’d look out the windshield.

“Because it doesn’t do any good,” he’d say. “It never has.”



Then came that Tuesday.


It was a work-from-home day. I was at the kitchen table with my laptop, going through a stack of insurance claims for a knee replacement that Blue Cross had denied three times.

Elsie was home from school. It was a teacher in-service day. She was upstairs in her room playing with her stuffed animals.

At two-fifteen, the doorbell rang.

I opened the door.

Piper. And Tucker. And Brody.

No phone call. No text. No heads-up.

Typical Piper.


“Surprise!” she said. “We were in the neighborhood!”

They were not in the neighborhood. Nobody is ever in our neighborhood. It’s a cul-de-sac.

“Hi, Piper,” I said. “I’m actually working today—”

“Oh, don’t mind us!” she said, already coming in the door. “The boys have the day off school too. In-service day. I thought they could play with Elsie. You just keep working. We’ll be quiet as mice.”


The boys ran straight past me and up the stairs.

They didn’t take off their shoes. They didn’t say hi. They just ran.

“Boys!” Piper called after them. Not very loud. “Be nice to your cousin!”

Then she walked into my living room and sat down on my couch. She kicked off her sandals. She put her feet up on my coffee table.

“Got any of that iced tea?” she said.


I made her iced tea.

I sat back down at my laptop.

Piper talked for an hour. About her neighbor’s new pool. About her husband, Craig, who was working too many hours at the car dealership. About a fight she had with a woman at the PTA meeting over the fall carnival.

I said “mm-hm” and “wow” and “that’s crazy” and tried to work.

Upstairs, I could hear the kids. Running. Thumping. Some yelling. Some laughing. At one point, something fell over and there was a loud crash.

“Boys!” Piper called. Without getting up. “Be careful!”

Related Posts

Two Boys Emptied My Daughters Savings Jar Until I Taught Their Mother A Lesson

I told him. Everything. Piper showing up without calling. The boys running upstairs in their shoes. The crash. Tucker with his hands jammed in his hoodie pocket….

Two Boys Emptied My Daughters Savings Jar Until I Taught Their Mother A Lesson

At three-thirty, Piper looked at her phone. “Oh, shoot,” she said. “I’ve gotta pick up Craig’s dry cleaning before five. Boys! Let’s go!” The boys came thundering…

Two Boys Emptied My Daughters Savings Jar Until I Taught Their Mother A Lesson

I’m thirty-four years old, and I honestly never thought I’d have to argue with a grown woman about stealing from a six-year-old. But there I was. Standing…

My Husband’s Final Wish Was to Donate His Organs, but the Secret He Left With His Doctor Changed Everything

Afterward, I sat alone in a small office signing the final donation forms. Beth had tried to help, but I asked her to give me a few…

My Husband’s Final Wish Was to Donate His Organs, but the Secret He Left With His Doctor Changed Everything

That evening, we sat together on the porch. We had a little wooden bench out front that Mark had made the first summer we lived there. It…

My Husband’s Final Wish Was to Donate His Organs, but the Secret He Left With His Doctor Changed Everything

We wanted a baby right away. We didn’t get one right away. It took almost three years. There were months when I’d be two days late and…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *