He Called Me an Old Man and Told Me to Get Off His Hunting Land, but He Had No Idea Who I Was

Twenty minutes later, a green pickup truck with a light bar and the seal of the State of Connecticut on the door rolled slowly up my lane and stopped beside the gap in the wall. The Department of Energy and Environmental Protection. Environmental Conservation Police. EnCon, everybody in the hills calls them.

The officer who stepped out was a woman about forty, compact and square-shouldered, in a green uniform with a badge and a sidearm and a brown campaign hat. Her name tag said CRUZ. She stood by her truck for a moment and looked at everything without saying a word. At the gap in the wall. At the scattered stones. At the broken sign in the leaves. At the tractor ruts through the ferns. Then at the eleven men in orange, standing in an uneasy cluster by their trucks, not looking at each other.

Silas hurried toward her across the frosty grass with his receipts held high.

“Officer!” he called. “Arrest that man. I’ve got eleven paid hunting passes right here. He’s interfering with lawful hunters.”

Officer Cruz didn’t reach for the papers.

“Mr. Dalton,” she said. “Who owns this parcel?”

“I control it,” Silas said. “Same thing.”

She looked at him for a long moment. Then she turned to me.

“Sir,” she said. “Your name?”

“Franklin Weller.”

She paused. Something moved across her face. She tilted her head slightly, the way people do when a name rings a bell somewhere in the back of their memory.

“Franklin Weller,” she repeated carefully. “The prosecutor?”

“Retired,” I said. “I was the State’s Attorney for the Litchfield Judicial District until six years ago. Before that, assistant state’s attorney for twenty-five years.”

She nodded slowly. “I read your opinion on the Fiske case at the academy,” she said. “The jacklighting case. In 2009.”

“That was the judge’s opinion,” I said. “I only wrote the brief.”

Her eyes moved from my face to the paper in Silas’s outstretched hand. The whole field had gone quiet. Even Silas.

“Mr. Dalton,” she said, holding out her palm. “Let me see exactly what you sold them.”

Silas pulled the top receipt free and handed it to her.

It was a single sheet, printed on a home computer, with a cheap clip-art picture of a deer in the corner. At the top, in bold letters, it said WELLER WOODS HUNTING LEASE, 2025 ARCHERY SEASON. Below that, a paragraph granting the bearer permission to hunt deer and turkey by bow on the Weller property, Haldane Corners, forty acres, from October through December. Paid in full, four hundred dollars, cash. And then, at the bottom, two signature lines.

Officer Cruz looked down at the signature line, and stopped moving.

She read it twice. Then she looked up at me, standing in my own field in my old barn coat with my dog sitting at my feet. Then back down at the paper.

The bottom line said Hunter, with one of the men’s names signed on it. Michael Ferreira.

The top line said Landowner.

And on it, in blue ink, in a careful, slanting hand that looked very much like mine, it said Franklin J. Weller. And under that, in smaller print, by S. Dalton, Executor of the Estate.

“Mr. Weller,” Officer Cruz said quietly. “Did you sign this?”

“No, ma’am,” I said.

“Is this your signature?”

“It’s my name,” I said. “It isn’t my hand. But it’s close.” I looked at Silas. “Somebody practiced.”

Officer Cruz looked at the receipt for another long moment. Then she held out her other hand to Silas.

“All of them, please,” she said. “Every receipt.”

Chapter Three: Eleven Men

She collected all eleven receipts. Every one was the same. Same clip-art deer. Same paragraph. Same forged signature on the landowner line. Franklin J. Weller, by S. Dalton, Executor of the Estate. Eleven men had each paid him four hundred dollars in cash. Four thousand four hundred dollars.

Then Officer Cruz did something I hadn’t expected. She walked over to the hunters first. Not to Silas. She stood in front of the eleven men by their trucks and spoke to them in a calm, level voice.

“Gentlemen,” she said. “Connecticut law requires anybody hunting on private land to carry written permission from the landowner. You all know that. It’s in the hunting guide. It’s on your license.” She held up the stack of receipts. “Each of you thought this was that permission. It isn’t. The landowner is standing right there. He’s alive. He didn’t sign these.”

The men looked at each other.

“I’m not going to write any of you up,” she said. “I don’t believe any of you knew. But I need you to unstring your bows, put them in your vehicles, and leave this property now. And I’m going to need each of your names and phone numbers, because you’re all going to be witnesses.”

They did what she asked. Quietly. One by one, they put their bows in their trucks. The man with the gray goatee, the one who’d asked me if this was my property, came over to me before he got in his truck. He held out his hand.

“Mike Ferreira,” he said. “From Torrington. I’m sorry, Mr. Weller. I should’ve known. When we drove in through that hole in the wall, I thought, who knocks down a wall to get onto land he’s leasing? I should’ve turned around right then.”

I shook his hand. “You asked the right question, Mr. Ferreira,” I said. “Before you started hunting. Most men wouldn’t have.”

The thin man with the wire-rimmed glasses came over too. He said his name was Arthur Bell, a retired machinist from Winsted. He said he’d paid Silas the four hundred out of his Social Security.

“He told me you died in April,” Arthur Bell said. “Heart attack. He said the estate was tied up in probate, and the heirs were out of state, and he was handling the property. He said it like he’d been to your funeral.” He shook his head. “I said I was sorry for his loss. He thanked me.”

I didn’t say anything to that. I didn’t know what to say.

When the last truck had gone down my lane, it was just the three of us in the field. Officer Cruz, Silas Dalton, and me. My dog, an old black Lab named Duke, sat at my feet and looked at Silas.

Officer Cruz turned to him.

“Mr. Dalton,” she said. “You took four thousand four hundred dollars from eleven men by telling them the owner of this land was dead and you had authority to lease it. You signed his name to eleven documents. You damaged a stone wall that’s on the state’s list of historic agricultural walls. You tore down a posted sign and broke it in front of a witness. And you called me out here to report the actual owner as a trespasser.”

Silas didn’t say anything. His face had gone from red to gray.

“I’m going to ask you to come down to the barracks in Harwinton with me,” she said. “You’re not under arrest yet. I want to give you the chance to explain.”

He looked at me then. A long, strange look. And I saw something in his face I recognized. Not just anger. Something older than that. Something I’d seen across a courtroom twenty-nine years before, in the face of a skinny eighteen-year-old boy sitting in the back row of Litchfield Superior Court, watching me prosecute his father.

“You don’t remember me,” Silas said quietly. “Do you, Mr. Weller.”

“I remember you, Silas,” I said. “I remember your father.”

Chapter Four: The Wall

After they left, I walked up to the gap in the wall alone.

Duke came with me, as he always does, padding through the frosted leaves at my heels. I stood at the edge of the hole Silas’s tractor had punched through Josiah Haldane’s wall and looked at the stones scattered in the leaves. Big fieldstones, gray and brown and rust-colored, some of them two hundred pounds. Pulled out of the ground by a farmer and his oxen in the 1780s, when this whole country was being cleared for sheep pasture, and stacked by hand into a wall that stood for two and a half centuries.

My wife used to walk this wall with me every evening. Eleanor. Nell, everybody called her. She taught fourth grade at Haldane Corners Elementary for thirty-four years, and she knew the history of every wall and cellar hole and mill dam in these hills. She’d stop at this spot sometimes and put her hand flat on the top stones and say, “Somebody’s grandfather carried these, Frank. Every one of them. One at a time.”

She died three years ago. Breast cancer. We’d been married forty-four years. Our son lives in Seattle and our daughter in Baltimore, and they call on Sundays, and they keep asking when I’m going to sell the place and move somewhere smaller.

I always tell them not yet.

I looked down at the tractor ruts through her ferns. The ostrich ferns were the worst. Their crowns were crushed into the mud. Some of them might come back in the spring. Most of them wouldn’t.

I knelt down, slowly, because my knees aren’t what they were, and picked up one of the smaller stones from the gap. Maybe forty pounds. I tried to set it back on the wall. I couldn’t lift it high enough. I set it down in the leaves and knelt there beside it, with my hand on top of it, the way Nell used to.

Duke lay down beside me and put his chin on my knee.

Chapter Five: Earl Dalton

Twenty-nine years ago, in the winter of 1996, I prosecuted Silas Dalton’s father.

Earl Dalton farmed the place to the north of mine, on the other side of the stone wall. He was a dairy farmer, like his father and grandfather before him, with sixty cows and a falling-down barn and more debt than any man should carry. The price of milk had dropped through the floor that year. Half the dairies in Litchfield County went under.

That January, a game warden caught Earl in my woods at two in the morning with a spotlight and a .30-30 rifle and a dead doe in the back of his truck. Jacklighting, it’s called. Shining a light in a deer’s eyes at night so it freezes, and shooting it. It’s illegal in every state in the country. It’s illegal because it isn’t hunting. It’s just killing.

Earl had done it six times that winter, the warden testified. In my woods. Six deer. He said he’d been feeding his family on venison since November because he couldn’t afford groceries. He had a wife and two kids. Silas was the oldest.

I was the assistant state’s attorney who handled the case. I was forty-three years old, and ambitious, and sure of everything. I’d prosecuted a lot of poachers. Most of them were men like Earl. Poor, rural, desperate, and stubborn. And I believed then, with my whole heart, that the law was the law. If you let one man jacklight deer because he’s hungry, you have to let them all.

Related Posts

My Husband Sold My Car To Make Me Lose Weight Until One Phone Call Changed Everything

He popped the beer open. “Just ask Dana,” he said. “If you’re not fit enough to walk all the way across town. That’s what a carpool is…

My Husband Sold My Car To Make Me Lose Weight Until One Phone Call Changed Everything

There was a pause. “Where’s your little car?” “Lucas sold it.” A longer pause. “He what?” “He sold it. Last night. To a guy from his work….

My Husband Sold My Car To Make Me Lose Weight Until One Phone Call Changed Everything

I’d trusted him with that. Something I was embarrassed about. Something I’d never said out loud to anyone. Now, standing in my kitchen with his toast and…

My Husband Sold My Car To Make Me Lose Weight Until One Phone Call Changed Everything

Lucas came through the kitchen in a towel, leaving wet footprints from the back door all the way to my stove. “Where are my pants?!” “In the…

He Called Me an Old Man and Told Me to Get Off His Hunting Land, but He Had No Idea Who I Was

I asked for the maximum. Earl Dalton got thirty days in the Litchfield County jail, a fine of two thousand dollars, and the revocation of his hunting…

He Called Me an Old Man and Told Me to Get Off His Hunting Land, but He Had No Idea Who I Was

“Sir,” he asked, “is this your property?” “Every acre you’re standing on,” I said. Silas climbed down from the truck. He’s forty-seven, a big man, six foot…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *