“Do you want me to go over there?” she said quietly.
I watched the elevator doors close on my husband.
I shook my head.
“Okay,” Rachel said. “Then we’re going somewhere else.”
She took my arm. Not hard. Just firm. Like you’d take the arm of somebody who might fall over.
She walked me out of the Harmon Hotel and onto the sidewalk.
The air was cold. November. It smelled like wet leaves and car exhaust.
“I’ll drive you home,” Rachel said.
“I can drive.”
“Laurel.”
“I can drive,” I said again. “I’m fine. I’m fine.”
She looked at me for a long moment.
“You’re not fine,” she said. “But okay. Call me the second you get home.”
I walked to my car in the parking garage.
I got in. I shut the door. I put my hands on the steering wheel.
And I sat there.
For forty minutes, I sat there, and I didn’t start the car. I just sat in the cold garage and watched my hands shake on the wheel.
Every few minutes, I’d look at the photograph again.
Martin’s arm around her waist. Her hand on his chest. Their faces together under the brass chandelier.
The blue checked shirt I’d ironed.
At home, I cried until my face hurt.
I didn’t do it the way people do in movies. I didn’t throw anything. I didn’t scream. I just sat on the floor of our bedroom with my back against the bed and cried with my mouth open until my throat was raw.
The bedroom window was letting in cold air again. I could hear it whistling through the gap at the top.
That’s an expensive job. It can wait.
Martin sent a text at 6:04 p.m.
Made it. Long evening ahead. Love you.
I read it three times.
Made it. Twenty minutes across town.
Long evening ahead.
Love you.
I didn’t reply.
I sat there on the bedroom floor and thought about what would happen next if I did nothing.
Tomorrow, he’d send another message. Busy day. Meetings till late. Miss you.
Thursday, maybe a call. He’d sound tired. He’d say the client was being difficult.
And Friday, he’d come home. He’d drop his suitcase by the stairs. He’d want clean clothes and dinner. He’d kiss my cheek and ask what I’d done all week.
And I’d be expected to act like I didn’t know anything.
To help him pretend those four days had been work.
I opened the photograph again.
No, I thought. I’m not going to help him pretend.
He’d have to look at that picture. And answer for what he’d done.
Rachel called at seven.
“Have you talked to him?”
“Not yet.”
“You don’t have to decide everything tonight, Laurel.”
“He was laughing at me,” I said.
My voice broke on laughing.
Rachel didn’t say anything. She just stayed on the line while I tried to breathe. In. Out. In. Out. She stayed quiet for almost a full minute. She didn’t try to fill it.
“When he comes home Friday,” I said finally, “I’m putting the picture in front of him. And he can explain what I saw.”
“Call me before you do it.”
“What if I can’t say it without crying?”
“Then you cry,” Rachel said. “He can still answer you. Crying doesn’t make the question any less real.”
I’d spent the whole afternoon rehearsing how I’d look when I faced him. Calm. Cold. Strong. Like a woman in a movie.
I hadn’t let myself imagine needing help.
“Okay,” I said.
Before we hung up, I asked her something.
“Will you check on me Friday? When he comes home? I just… I want somebody to know.”
“I’ll be watching from my kitchen window,” Rachel said. “If you need me, turn your porch light on and off twice. I’ll be there in thirty seconds.”
“That’s very dramatic.”
“I’ve been divorced for nine years,” Rachel said. “I’ve earned dramatic.”
I almost laughed.
After she hung up, I emailed the photograph to myself. Then I saved a copy to a folder on my laptop. Then I saved another copy to a cloud account Martin didn’t know the password to.
I’m a project manager. I know about backups.
Then I turned off the kitchen light and went upstairs.
His pillow still had the dent in it from that morning. The shape of his head.
I stood there and looked at it for a long time.
Then I turned it over. So the dent was underneath.
I lay down on my own side of the bed. I didn’t touch the empty space. I pulled the blanket up to my chin and listened to the wind whistling through the broken window.
I didn’t sleep much.
I kept thinking about Columbus.
About our first apartment, on High Street, above a bakery. The whole place smelled like bread at four in the morning. Martin used to go down in his pajamas and buy day-old croissants from the baker, a big Polish man named Stan, for fifty cents each.
We had a mattress on the floor for the first year. A card table for a dining table. We ate takeout Chinese food on the floor and played Scrabble until two in the morning, and Martin always cheated and tried to say made-up words were real.
“Quizzle is absolutely a word.”
“It is not a word, Martin.”
“It’s a cross between a quiz and a puzzle. Very common in Ohio.”
I married him two years later in my parents’ backyard in Dayton. He cried during his vows. He promised to always tell me the truth, even when it was hard.
I used to think about that vow every time we had a fight. He promised to tell me the truth.
I lay there in the dark and thought about it again.
Not a clue.
The hospital called at 8:40 the next morning.
I was at the kitchen table with a cup of coffee I hadn’t touched. I’d called in sick to work. I’d told my boss I had a migraine. It was the first sick day I’d taken in three years.
My phone rang. A number I didn’t know.
“Is this Laurel Hayes?”
“Yes.”
“This is Brookfield Memorial Hospital. Your husband, Martin Hayes, has asked us to contact you. He’s awake and being assessed. He’d like you to come in.”
For a moment, I couldn’t say anything at all.
I’d spent the whole night imagining confronting him. Planning what I’d say. Where I’d stand. What my face would look like.
And now a stranger was telling me he was in the hospital.
I stood up so fast my chair scraped across the floor.
“What happened? How badly is he hurt?”
“He’s being assessed for a wrist injury,” the woman said. “He’s conscious and he’s able to speak with you.”
A wrist.
I sat back down.
The relief came first. A big wave of it.
And right behind the relief came anger. Because I hated that I was relieved. I hated that after everything I’d seen, after not a clue, after the photograph and the night on the bedroom floor, he could still scare me that easily.
I could still be afraid for him.
He could still reach me.
She gave me the address. Brookfield Memorial. Twenty minutes away.
My car was in the driveway. But after that call, I didn’t trust myself to drive. My hands were shaking again.
I ordered a cab.
During the ride, I held my phone in my lap. I kept opening the photograph and closing it. Opening it. Closing it.
The cab driver had the radio on. An oldies station. “Stand By Me.”
I almost asked him to turn it off.
I wanted to demand an explanation. I wanted to walk into that hospital and throw my phone at Martin’s head.
But first, I needed to see for myself that he was all right.
I hated that too.
At the front desk, I gave Martin’s name. A nurse with purple scrubs and a tired face pointed me down a hallway to a small waiting area by the emergency treatment rooms.
I walked down the hall.
He was sitting in a plastic chair by the window.
When he saw me, he stood up.
“Thank God,” he said.
He sounded relieved to see me. Really, truly relieved.
I couldn’t understand it.
Surely I was the last person in the world he wanted to see right now.
And then I saw who was sitting two chairs away from him.
The woman from the hotel.
She looked different without the cream coat and the shiny hair. Her hair was scraped back into a crooked ponytail. She was wearing a gray sweatshirt that was much too big for her. Her face was pale and blotchy. No makeup.
She was holding her left wrist against her stomach.
I stopped walking.
Martin reached for me. He tried to take my arm.
I moved it away.
“What happened?” I said.
“Can we talk somewhere else?” Martin said. “Just for a minute?”
The woman stood up.
“Martin,” she said sharply. “We don’t have time for that.”
“I’m talking to my wife, Vanessa.”